Scantegrity https://scantegrity.org/blog The Blog Mon, 07 Nov 2011 20:54:37 +0000 en hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 Remotegrity: First Voter-Verifiable Internet Voting for Public Office https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/11/05/remotegrity-first-voter-verifiable-internet-voting-for-public-office/#utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=remotegrity-first-voter-verifiable-internet-voting-for-public-office https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/11/05/remotegrity-first-voter-verifiable-internet-voting-for-public-office/#comments Sun, 06 Nov 2011 02:12:29 +0000 Richard Carback https://scantegrity.org/blog/?p=1051 On November 8, 2011, absentee voters in Takoma Park, Maryland, will have the option to verify their votes for mayor and city council using a new Internet voting system called Remotegrity. Internet voting has been used to elect government officials before (for example, in Switzerland, Estonia, and Norway), but what is new here is that voters mail in paper ballots and use the Internet to independently verify that their votes have been received by the city and recorded correctly. Anyone can check online that the recorded votes were tallied correctly.

Dr. Filip Zagorski, computer scientist at The George Washington University, explains “Through the hybrid use of paper ballots and Internet verification, Remotegrity combines the best of both worlds to provide a very high degree of security even against malware and insider attack.” Portions of the underlying research in cryptography and secure server design were supported by the National Science Foundation and the Polish Ministry of Science and Higher Education.

Voters who have requested to vote by mail receive a ballot which they mark and mail in, but they can also verify their vote on-line in the Remotegrity system, without revealing how they voted. In future elections, the same online procedure may cast votes and physical mailing of paper ballots may be optional or omitted.

The city will also use the Scantegrity voting system for voters who cast their ballot in person, as it did in 2009. The integrated Scantegrity and Remotegrity systems offer full end-to-end voter-verifiability, in which voters casting ballots from home or in person can verify that their votes were correctly cast, collected, and counted.

Additionally, this year, the city will provide an audio interface for marking ballots. The interface, named Audiotegrity, developed by researchers at The George Washington University, will enable voters with difficulty marking paper ballots to mark ballots independently using an electronic interface. Mr. Noel Runyan, a usability and accessibility expert, provided pro bono design advice to the Audiotegrity team.

With a grant from the federal Election Assistance Commission, and support from the non-profit Voting Systems Institute, researchers from UMBC will survey voters and election officials as well as conduct focus groups around their experiences using these new voting systems.
__________________________________________________
For more information:
Dr. David Chaum, Voting Systems Institute, david@chaum.com, mobile 818 512 1024
Prof. Poorvi L. Vora, Department of Computer Science, GW, poorvi@gwu.edu, mobile 202 262 1101
Dr. Alan T. Sherman, Dept. of CSEE, UMBC, sherman@umbc.edu, mobile 410 963 4779

http://www.scantegrity.org
http://www.usenix.org/events/sec10/tech/full_papers/Carback.pdf
http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/2009/rivest-voting.html
Video – How to vote using Scantegrity: http://vimeo.com/31647826

]]> https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/11/05/remotegrity-first-voter-verifiable-internet-voting-for-public-office/feed/ 0 How to Vote with Scantegrity https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/11/05/how-to-vote-with-scantegrity/#utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=how-to-vote-with-scantegrity https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/11/05/how-to-vote-with-scantegrity/#comments Sun, 06 Nov 2011 02:04:02 +0000 Richard Carback https://scantegrity.org/blog/?p=1046 Our team made this video for the upcoming election:

]]> https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/11/05/how-to-vote-with-scantegrity/feed/ 0 Auditing the Takoma Park 2011 Election https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/08/20/auditing-the-takoma-park-2011-election/#utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=auditing-the-takoma-park-2011-election https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/08/20/auditing-the-takoma-park-2011-election/#comments Sat, 20 Aug 2011 15:15:05 +0000 Richard Carback https://scantegrity.org/blog/?p=1033 We are happy to announce the following independent auditors for the 2011 Election:

  • Dr. Roberto Araújo—He will be performing audits of the election data. He is a professor at Universidade Federal do Pará
    (Brazil). He holds a Ph.D. in Informatics from Theoretical Computer Science group at TU-Darmstadt (Germany) and is electronic voting researcher.
  • Lillie Coney—Also an auditor during the last election, she will be performing random ballot audits. She is the Associate Director of the Electronic Privacy Information Center, a public interest research organization in Washington, DC. EPIC was established to focus public attention on civil liberties issues. Ms. Coney joined EPIC in 2004 to head up the organization’s voting and privacy project.
  • Neal McBurnett—Founder of the ElectionAudits software package, a former distinguished member of the technical staff at Bell Labs, an Ubuntu Linux member, and a prolific supporter of open systems and free software. He will be performing audits of the election data.
  • Marco Ramilli—A security researcher who has helped us fix several problems with our websites, Marco will be performing security review of our software. He is a Ph.D. student working with the UC Davis E-Voting Research Group.

The auditors from 2009 have moved on to other exciting work. Dr. Ben Adida is now working for Mozilla. Dr. Filip Zagorski is working with us as a postdoc at GWU, and is head of the work for Remotegrity. Their code will still be available for anyone to use to audit the election this year:

Additionally, all of the data will be signed, and the public key that will be used can be found on our subversion repository, on the mit pgp keyserver, and below: 

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.17 (Darwin)
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=lgdW
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
]]> https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/08/20/auditing-the-takoma-park-2011-election/feed/ 0 Remotegrity Frequently Asked Questions https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/07/07/remotegrity-frequently-asked-questions/#utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=remotegrity-frequently-asked-questions https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/07/07/remotegrity-frequently-asked-questions/#comments Fri, 08 Jul 2011 03:39:36 +0000 Richard Carback https://scantegrity.org/blog/?p=1030 We received a lot of questions about Remotegrity, and in response I
posted a Remotegrity FAQ (written by Drs. Vora and Zagorski) to the wiki:

https://scantegrity.org/wiki/index.php/Remotegrity_Frequently_Asked_Questions

If we are missing something, please let us know by adding it to the Talk page on the wiki.

]]> https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/07/07/remotegrity-frequently-asked-questions/feed/ 0 electionlineWeekly: “Takoma Park, Md. tests online absentee voting” https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/06/16/electionlineweekly-takoma-park-md-tests-online-absentee-voting/#utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=electionlineweekly-takoma-park-md-tests-online-absentee-voting https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/06/16/electionlineweekly-takoma-park-md-tests-online-absentee-voting/#comments Fri, 17 Jun 2011 03:35:20 +0000 Richard Carback https://scantegrity.org/blog/?p=1027 From the article:

A small group of students, led by George Washington University computer science professor Poorvi Vora, spearheaded a test for online absentee voting in Takoma Park in partnership with Scantegrity and Remotegrity.

Remotegrity is the name given to the absentee return over internet option.

]]> https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/06/16/electionlineweekly-takoma-park-md-tests-online-absentee-voting/feed/ 0 FairVote: “Internet Voting 2.0 and Other Advances in Election Technology in Takoma Park” https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/06/16/fairvote-internet-voting-2-0-and-other-advances-in-election-technology-in-takoma-park/#utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=fairvote-internet-voting-2-0-and-other-advances-in-election-technology-in-takoma-park https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/06/16/fairvote-internet-voting-2-0-and-other-advances-in-election-technology-in-takoma-park/#comments Fri, 17 Jun 2011 03:30:17 +0000 Richard Carback https://scantegrity.org/blog/?p=1025 From the article:

FairVote’s home city of Takoma Park, Md., hosted a test on Thursday of an innovative new interface for absentee voters that would allow them to verify that their voted were counted in the final tally of this November’s citywide elections, which use instant runoff voting. To be clear, the absentee voting interface tested would NOT necessarily involve casting ballots via the Internet. A potential add-in tested alongside the verification system could provide that option in the future, however. That option effectively addresses concerns about voter anonymity, but the potential for virtual shenanigans by hackers who know more about the electronic frontier than any election official endures as the fiberglass ceiling for any Internet voting system.

Please note that Scantegrity is not affiliated with FairVote. We are a non-profit research organization, and we do not do any political advocacy. We have been accused of various affiliation before, and there is a comment thread where I tried to address specific accusations.

]]> https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/06/16/fairvote-internet-voting-2-0-and-other-advances-in-election-technology-in-takoma-park/feed/ 0 Maryland Gazette: “Takoma Park explores online absentee voting” https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/06/16/maryland-gazette-takoma-park-explores-online-absentee-voting/#utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=maryland-gazette-takoma-park-explores-online-absentee-voting https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/06/16/maryland-gazette-takoma-park-explores-online-absentee-voting/#comments Fri, 17 Jun 2011 03:21:48 +0000 Richard Carback https://scantegrity.org/blog/?p=1022 From the article:

“The city Board of Elections is working with Scantegrity, a research group that ran the city’s 2009 elections, to develop a system in which absentee voters could vote online. The city will still be conducting traditional voting at polling places, regardless of whether an online absentee system is implemented, City Clerk Jessie Carpenter said.”

]]> https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/06/16/maryland-gazette-takoma-park-explores-online-absentee-voting/feed/ 0 Will Takoma Park Voters Be Able to Cast Ballots Online for the 2011 City Election? https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/05/22/will-takoma-park-voters-be-able-to-cast-ballots-online-for-the-2011-city-election/#utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=will-takoma-park-voters-be-able-to-cast-ballots-online-for-the-2011-city-election https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/05/22/will-takoma-park-voters-be-able-to-cast-ballots-online-for-the-2011-city-election/#comments Mon, 23 May 2011 01:45:56 +0000 Richard Carback https://scantegrity.org/blog/?p=1011 This post is an attempt to provide more information and clarify any misconceptions from an article with the title Takoma Park Voters Will Be Able to Cast Ballots Online for 2011 City Election on May 20th.

Last week we presented an early stage proposal for absentee voting at Takoma Park’s weekly board of elections. Our understanding is that absentee voters will comprise less than 50 people, or .5% of the eligible voting population of approximately 10,000 voters. There are no current plans or agreements in place to deploy it during the election.

We have no intention of using the system without thorough peer review and testing. The board meeting was one of a couple we have attended in order to get feedback from the Board regarding reasonable tasks to expect from absentee voters before we finalize the protocol for review by security experts. Thus, the Board also does not consider this in any way a finalized issue. In particular, any process that is used in the election would have to be finally approved by both the Board and the City Council.

This is not, technically speaking, an internet voting system. This is an option for voters to cast and verify absentee ballots using the internet. Voters voting from the polling booth on election day in the 2009 election were able to verify that their votes were counted. This year we would like to extend this capability to absentee voters. We also want to allow voters who may not have mailed their ballot early enough to vote, and to allow voters to check that the ballot was counted and was not lost in the mail. Voters returning ballots by smail mail can perform the same check. So, we are making an additional feature available—auditability—to absentee voters without making their privacy any worse.

Voters would not be downloading a ballot. As the article describes, they will receive their ballots as usual by the postal mail system. Further, as was demonstrated during the meeting covered in the report, those voters who choose to vote over the internet do not enter their votes, but instead enter a code corresponding to the voter. This code is random per ballot and per candidate and does not reveal the candidate. At no point does any computer system on the internet know for which candidate a voter has voted.

Our team is doing exactly what we did to optical scan voting systems in the absentee voting context:

  1. We are not taking away from the original system, this is an add-on only.
  2. We are adding auditability. The voter can check that her vote is included in the tally without making privacy worse.
  3. We are making it optional—the voter is not asked or required to do anything outside of the normal absentee ballot process. He or she can ignore it.

Note that, because this is absentee voting, there is much less protection available to keep the ballots private. The voter can still choose to give the materials to a coercer, photograph the ballot, etc—just like any absentee balloting system.

Overall, we are extremely pleased with this coverage. At the same time, however, we want to make clear the scope of this project and our approach. As soon as we have finished writing up the proposal, we will post it on this blog. We will also produce a detailed report soon and are also hoping to submit the proposal to a peer-reviewed venue this summer.

Lastly, opinions in our group vary on internet voting, and most are opposed to or extremely cautious about it. This is partly why we are being so conservative with this proposal. You can read more about them in the following links:

  1. Thoughts on UOCAVA Voting by Ron Rivest
  2. When internet voting ruled the Earth by Aleks Essex

As always, anyone who has questions or wishes to receive updates about what we are doing can use the contact form or join our mailing lists.

]]> https://scantegrity.org/blog/2011/05/22/will-takoma-park-voters-be-able-to-cast-ballots-online-for-the-2011-city-election/feed/ 0 Ron Rivest at MSR https://scantegrity.org/blog/2010/08/01/ron-rivest-at-msr/#utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=ron-rivest-at-msr https://scantegrity.org/blog/2010/08/01/ron-rivest-at-msr/#comments Sun, 01 Aug 2010 17:42:52 +0000 Richard Carback https://scantegrity.org/blog/?p=1009 Last March, Ron presented at Microsoft Research’s Workshop on Voting Technology. They posted video and an accompanying slide show of the talk.

]]> https://scantegrity.org/blog/2010/08/01/ron-rivest-at-msr/feed/ 0 Final Audit (Meeting Four) Posted for Takoma Park’s November 3rd 2009 Election https://scantegrity.org/blog/2009/11/07/final-audit-meeting-four-posted-for-takoma-parks-november-3rd-2009-election/#utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=final-audit-meeting-four-posted-for-takoma-parks-november-3rd-2009-election https://scantegrity.org/blog/2009/11/07/final-audit-meeting-four-posted-for-takoma-parks-november-3rd-2009-election/#comments Sat, 07 Nov 2009 13:50:00 +0000 Richard Carback https://scantegrity.org/blog/?p=1003 Here’s the list of files:
  1. 0b09df11097038ab861d6091e81b83e24f39163a  ./djia-stock-prices-14-Oct-09.txt
  2. be7508d86b311b51c5c9cfadea9f23051dd77acb  ./ward1/MeetingFourIn.xml
  3. b8913d2f7c3229587b681785c78fd766e45ba213  ./ward1/MeetingFourOut.xml
  4. a317ef3f8d3ee5b6c8fbdd81d0b2aa4525536227  ./ward1/PrintAuditBallots.xml
  5. 105da835e157419c8c7226c60e4f974c763bdaf6  ./ward1/PrintAuditMixnet.xml
  6. 4c2bac2a7375e27ddb72e8107ce460558d5a4a5a  ./ward1/ReplyToContestedCodes.xml
  7. 73554e741d69cad7d5264b74ab756305f50c1be0  ./ward1/SpoiledBallotsFromScanner.xml
  8. 440d840786f16822dc2c270fcbfaf8113dfa75df  ./ward1/SpoiledBallotsPid.xml
  9. adb410a66ae203bfa0b6bbdb963fe4af5e8caf9c  ./ward2/MeetingFourIn.xml
  10. 907a1d9dfd180acdd442ae91800a0371537f3d44  ./ward2/MeetingFourOut.xml
  11. 09aef26844519771167c15da9e51be4bdf2a2ea0  ./ward2/PrintAuditBallots.xml
  12. fa598f86512975723db06e9b9eeceaec92b746f9  ./ward2/PrintAuditMixnet.xml
  13. d4564e745258d36a23975e2d5c8839649ab26ec4  ./ward2/ReplyToContestedCodes.xml
  14. 5f65f44af911c0caa3e042d2d19f864351ce4923  ./ward2/SpoiledBallotsFromScanner.xml
  15. a123007faac80ac9a06a74b6b9fb25f55aa417b9  ./ward2/SpoiledBallotsPid.xml
  16. fa4742d5504672dfce6eb2750fd87400f3d32ec8  ./ward3/MeetingFourIn.xml
  17. 9a97ebb615f815d1954b6944fc102ad0c49c8bb4  ./ward3/MeetingFourOut.xml
  18. afd760d686397aebd0364c8f47da91dbfb44454b  ./ward3/PrintAuditBallots.xml
  19. a8b4bee76bdd2a2523cdcc615173e55f744b3e41  ./ward3/PrintAuditMixnet.xml
  20. e1c7a061d6abcba0e083e6e68bf40086e2408797  ./ward3/ReplyToContestedCodes.xml
  21. be4f5a9c6ddf2f6e3f88795abaa61bd642623f73  ./ward3/SpoiledBallotsFromScanner.xml
  22. 82134273bad243f1d2670df04773bf25203c4eeb  ./ward3/SpoiledBallotsPid.xml
  23. cf2fca46ac1dfeb48af7f43f2b861f6e686c9c37  ./ward4/MeetingFourIn.xml
  24. 0db5580a85566edacd6219943917f122e55a7b53  ./ward4/MeetingFourOut.xml
  25. c951619d363aa5db19cf9ad795b40e5519f618cc  ./ward4/PrintAuditBallots.xml
  26. c35eff3fb010a5e47ac12a874829f8b0763b2539  ./ward4/PrintAuditMixnet.xml
  27. bec616d20e8af1e4cce8efbc5adf48d738147574  ./ward4/ReplyToContestedCodes.xml
  28. c4a82715183e665cb106bbcc32b0091e5c20916f  ./ward4/SpoiledBallotsFromScanner.xml
  29. 35c749ebe920a547a304159f560d086ad0c3b4ab  ./ward4/SpoiledBallotsPid.xml
  30. 968472f25a4ca6c21d9e34d6956e81be0247021a  ./ward5/MeetingFourIn.xml
  31. a9df28445efd5a3c7736c94b6036b99542f5d3cf  ./ward5/MeetingFourOut.xml
  32. e8d099dfba457e27bcb2e9e53022caba2ec55e20  ./ward5/PrintAuditBallots.xml
  33. 57bec2f3f79329a7ab4afc082dcbafd0eeb54541  ./ward5/PrintAuditMixnet.xml
  34. 7ef4166284ce4cf131d26591d81102b436fbd244  ./ward5/ReplyToContestedCodes.xml
  35. e5e24ad90beeadc3bb42a9f71847b58d5dd97c02  ./ward5/SpoiledBallotsFromScanner.xml
  36. e5e24ad90beeadc3bb42a9f71847b58d5dd97c02  ./ward5/SpoiledBallotsPid.xml
  37. 2697e021a1f763aa03d42f644e70540660b5cc6c  ./ward6/MeetingFourIn.xml
  38. 9c31ff18113798e9d443565d691f5c1cefff5217  ./ward6/MeetingFourOut.xml
  39. ae9a132a1e025d7fb5adc884e803ae77fd9e1d7f  ./ward6/PrintAuditBallots.xml
  40. b9294c5249eba3e578107263c88b5adb80f9c8fb  ./ward6/PrintAuditMixnet.xml
  41. 0b9ba0fd45070d084f88620443356a9f6cc4a947  ./ward6/ReplyToContestedCodes.xml
  42. 197ad6baf83146e3afb22e910080d78646c0601b  ./ward6/SpoiledBallotsFromScanner.xml
  43. 360ca86dced88a5fa5f52842240316ae10cc1d00  ./ward6/SpoiledBallotsPid.xml
0b09df11097038ab861d6091e81b83e24f39163a  ./djia-stock-prices-14-Oct-09.txt
be7508d86b311b51c5c9cfadea9f23051dd77acb  ./ward1/MeetingFourIn.xml
b8913d2f7c3229587b681785c78fd766e45ba213  ./ward1/MeetingFourOut.xml
a317ef3f8d3ee5b6c8fbdd81d0b2aa4525536227  ./ward1/PrintAuditBallots.xml
105da835e157419c8c7226c60e4f974c763bdaf6  ./ward1/PrintAuditMixnet.xml
4c2bac2a7375e27ddb72e8107ce460558d5a4a5a  ./ward1/ReplyToContestedCodes.xml
73554e741d69cad7d5264b74ab756305f50c1be0  ./ward1/SpoiledBallotsFromScanner.xml
440d840786f16822dc2c270fcbfaf8113dfa75df  ./ward1/SpoiledBallotsPid.xml
adb410a66ae203bfa0b6bbdb963fe4af5e8caf9c  ./ward2/MeetingFourIn.xml
907a1d9dfd180acdd442ae91800a0371537f3d44  ./ward2/MeetingFourOut.xml
09aef26844519771167c15da9e51be4bdf2a2ea0  ./ward2/PrintAuditBallots.xml
fa598f86512975723db06e9b9eeceaec92b746f9  ./ward2/PrintAuditMixnet.xml
d4564e745258d36a23975e2d5c8839649ab26ec4  ./ward2/ReplyToContestedCodes.xml
5f65f44af911c0caa3e042d2d19f864351ce4923  ./ward2/SpoiledBallotsFromScanner.xml
a123007faac80ac9a06a74b6b9fb25f55aa417b9  ./ward2/SpoiledBallotsPid.xml
fa4742d5504672dfce6eb2750fd87400f3d32ec8  ./ward3/MeetingFourIn.xml
9a97ebb615f815d1954b6944fc102ad0c49c8bb4  ./ward3/MeetingFourOut.xml
afd760d686397aebd0364c8f47da91dbfb44454b  ./ward3/PrintAuditBallots.xml
a8b4bee76bdd2a2523cdcc615173e55f744b3e41  ./ward3/PrintAuditMixnet.xml
e1c7a061d6abcba0e083e6e68bf40086e2408797  ./ward3/ReplyToContestedCodes.xml
be4f5a9c6ddf2f6e3f88795abaa61bd642623f73  ./ward3/SpoiledBallotsFromScanner.xml
82134273bad243f1d2670df04773bf25203c4eeb  ./ward3/SpoiledBallotsPid.xml
cf2fca46ac1dfeb48af7f43f2b861f6e686c9c37  ./ward4/MeetingFourIn.xml
0db5580a85566edacd6219943917f122e55a7b53  ./ward4/MeetingFourOut.xml
c951619d363aa5db19cf9ad795b40e5519f618cc  ./ward4/PrintAuditBallots.xml
c35eff3fb010a5e47ac12a874829f8b0763b2539  ./ward4/PrintAuditMixnet.xml
bec616d20e8af1e4cce8efbc5adf48d738147574  ./ward4/ReplyToContestedCodes.xml
c4a82715183e665cb106bbcc32b0091e5c20916f  ./ward4/SpoiledBallotsFromScanner.xml
35c749ebe920a547a304159f560d086ad0c3b4ab  ./ward4/SpoiledBallotsPid.xml
968472f25a4ca6c21d9e34d6956e81be0247021a  ./ward5/MeetingFourIn.xml
a9df28445efd5a3c7736c94b6036b99542f5d3cf  ./ward5/MeetingFourOut.xml
e8d099dfba457e27bcb2e9e53022caba2ec55e20  ./ward5/PrintAuditBallots.xml
57bec2f3f79329a7ab4afc082dcbafd0eeb54541  ./ward5/PrintAuditMixnet.xml
7ef4166284ce4cf131d26591d81102b436fbd244  ./ward5/ReplyToContestedCodes.xml
e5e24ad90beeadc3bb42a9f71847b58d5dd97c02  ./ward5/SpoiledBallotsFromScanner.xml
e5e24ad90beeadc3bb42a9f71847b58d5dd97c02  ./ward5/SpoiledBallotsPid.xml
2697e021a1f763aa03d42f644e70540660b5cc6c  ./ward6/MeetingFourIn.xml
9c31ff18113798e9d443565d691f5c1cefff5217  ./ward6/MeetingFourOut.xml
ae9a132a1e025d7fb5adc884e803ae77fd9e1d7f  ./ward6/PrintAuditBallots.xml
b9294c5249eba3e578107263c88b5adb80f9c8fb  ./ward6/PrintAuditMixnet.xml
0b9ba0fd45070d084f88620443356a9f6cc4a947  ./ward6/ReplyToContestedCodes.xml
197ad6baf83146e3afb22e910080d78646c0601b  ./ward6/SpoiledBallotsFromScanner.xml
360ca86dced88a5fa5f52842240316ae10cc1d00  ./ward6/SpoiledBallotsPid.xml
]]> https://scantegrity.org/blog/2009/11/07/final-audit-meeting-four-posted-for-takoma-parks-november-3rd-2009-election/feed/ 0